top of page

24 Outrageous Auto Insurance Claims: The Most Bizarre Cases in America

Auto insurance claims are a common occurrence in the United States. Every day, thousands of drivers submit claims to their insurance companies for various reasons, including accidents, theft, or damage to their vehicles. While most claims are relatively straightforward, there are some cases that stand out for their sheer absurdity and bizarre nature.


car accident auto insurance
Photo by sasirin pamai

The world of auto insurance is filled with stories of fender benders and hailstorms, but sometimes, reality throws some truly curveball claims into the mix. Buckle up, folks, because we're diving into the hilarious, the outlandish, and the downright unbelievable insurance claims that have graced American soil.


1. The Flying Cow

In 2015, a man from rural Ohio made a claim on his auto insurance policy after a cow fell on his car from a bridge overhead. The incident occurred on a remote highway, and the man was lucky to escape with only minor injuries. The insurance claim amounted to $10,000 for the damage caused to the car. This bizarre case made national headlines and left insurance companies and the general public scratching their heads in disbelief.


 2. The Stolen Lunch

In 2018, a woman in New York made an auto insurance claim after her lunch was stolen from her car. Surprisingly, the woman had left her car unlocked while she popped into a store for a few minutes, and when she returned, she found that her homemade lunch had been stolen. The insurance claim totaled $500 for the cost of the stolen lunch, and this unusual case sparked a debate about the extent of coverage provided by auto insurance policies.


 3. The Runaway Shopping Cart

In 2017, a man in California filed an auto insurance claim after a runaway shopping cart slammed into his car in a supermarket parking lot. The incident caused significant damage to the vehicle, and the insurance claim amounted to $3,000. This case sparked discussions about the responsibility of the store and the liability of the insurance company in such unusual circumstances.


 4. The Mysterious Vandalism

In 2016, a woman in Florida made a bizarre auto insurance claim after her car was mysteriously vandalized with mustard and feathers. The incident occurred in a parking lot, and the insurance claim totaled $2,000 for the cleanup and repair of the car. This extraordinary case left both the insurance company and law enforcement baffled, as no clear motive or culprit was ever identified.


 5. The Uphill Battle

In 2019, a man in Colorado made an auto insurance claim after his car rolled downhill and crashed into a tree. The insurance claim amounted to $7,000 for the damage caused to the vehicle. This case raised questions about coverage for accidents that may seem absurd but still result in substantial financial losses for the insured.


 6. The Hair-Raising Accident

In 2014, a woman in Texas filed an auto insurance claim after her car collided with a stray wig on the highway. The incident caused significant damage to the vehicle, and the insurance claim totaled $5,000. This peculiar case brought attention to the unexpected hazards that drivers may face on the road and the corresponding coverage provided by auto insurance policies.


7. The Parked Car Surprise

In 2017, a man in Illinois made an auto insurance claim after a parked car spontaneously caught fire and damaged his vehicle. The insurance claim amounted to $4,000 for the repair and cleanup of the car. This unexpected incident raised questions about the responsibility of the car owner and the extent of coverage provided by auto insurance policies in such unusual circumstances.


8. The Pet Paradox

In 2015, a woman in Michigan filed an auto insurance claim after her car was damaged by her pet parrot, which had escaped from its cage and caused chaos inside the vehicle. The insurance claim totaled $6,000 for the cleanup and repair of the car. This extraordinary case shed light on the potential risks posed by pets to the integrity of a vehicle and the corresponding coverage provided by auto insurance policies.


9. The UFO Encounter

Perhaps one of the most outlandish auto insurance claims in America is the case of the UFO encounter. In 2009, a man in New Mexico filed a claim after his car was allegedly struck by a UFO. The insurance company was initially skeptical, but after investigating the incident and finding multiple witnesses who claimed to have seen the UFO, the claim was approved. This case remains one of the most bizarre and bewildering auto insurance claims in American history.


10. The Case of the Stolen Car...By a Toddler?

On August 2019, a couple in New York City experienced a shock when they discovered their car had been stolen, only to find out that the thief was a toddler. The young child managed to climb into the unattended car and drive it several blocks before crashing into a street sign. The couple's insurance company was left baffled by the circumstances and the sheer incompetence of the thief, resulting in an unusual claim process.


11. The Phantom Passenger

In another strange case, a woman in Texas filed an auto insurance claim after being involved in a car accident. The twist? She claimed that a ghost had caused the accident by grabbing the steering wheel and veering the car off the road. Despite the absurdity of her claim, the insurance company conducted a thorough investigation and found that there were no other passengers in the car at the time of the accident. The woman's claim was ultimately denied, but the bizarre nature of the incident left everyone involved perplexed.


12. Sticky Situation

In Arizona, a driver made headlines when he filed an insurance claim for the damage caused to his car by a swarm of bees. According to the driver, he had parked his car near a field of blooming flowers and returned to find the vehicle completely covered in bees and honey. The insurance company initially refused to believe the driver's story, but a thorough investigation revealed that a nearby beekeeper had lost control of several hives, resulting in the swarm that had attacked the car. The driver's claim was eventually approved, and the car was repaired.


13. The Gator Bait

Another peculiar case took place in Florida, where a driver made an insurance claim for the destruction of her car by a wayward alligator. The driver reported that she had parked her car near a swamp and returned to find the vehicle completely destroyed, with the alligator still clinging to the wreckage. The insurance company initially balked at the claim, citing the absurdity of an alligator attacking a parked car. However, further investigation revealed that the area was indeed known for its large and aggressive alligator population, and the driver's claim was ultimately accepted.


14. A Fishy Tale

In California, David Jones was driving his convertible on a sunny day on August 2016 when a seagull dropped a fish onto his windshield, causing it to shatter. His insurance claim of $30,000 for a new windshield and interior damage was initially met with skepticism, but after witness accounts and photo evidence, the claim was approved.


15. The Ostrich Odyssey

A Florida driver claimed over $10,000 after encountering an ostrich on the highway. The bird, apparently on the lam from a nearby farm, caused $6,000 in windshield and hood damage, while the remaining $4,000 were for "emotional distress" from the feathered fender bender. The insurance company balked, and the claim quickly became a local punchline.


16. The Sky's the Limit (Literally)

An Iowa farmer filed a $50,000 claim after his prized tractor was struck by a falling satellite. While an astronomical occurrence indeed, the claim was denied. Turns out, space debris and extraterrestrial damage weren't included in his policy (who could have predicted that?).


17. The Crabby Collision

A California fisherman attempted to claim $25,000 after his boat sank due to a crab claw stuck in the engine. The insurance company, smelling something fishy, denied the claim, citing negligence for operating a vessel with obstructed machinery.


18. The Hole in One (More Like Hole in Two)

A golfer in Arizona sought $8,000 in compensation after accidentally hitting his car with his own errant swing. Fortunately, the insurance company had a hole-in-one in terms of deductibles, leaving the golfer responsible for the self-inflicted damage.


19. The Flying Fish Fiasco

A Maine lobsterman filed a $15,000 claim after his boat was bombarded by a school of leaping sardines. The slippery projectiles caused dents and scratches, but the insurance company remained unmoved, citing "acts of nature" as an exclusion.


20. The Accidental Alpaca Auction

A Wyoming rancher's car collided with a runaway alpaca, forcing him to swerve into a ditch. He tried to claim $7,000 for repairs, but the insurance company only covered the car damage. The alpaca, thankfully unharmed, found a new home at a local auction, adding an unexpected twist to the tale.


21. The Up, Up, and Away Claim

A New Jersey driver reported their car stolen by... hot air balloons. They demanded $30,000 in compensation, claiming the balloons snatched their vehicle while parked at a festival. The flimsy story, lighter than air itself, quickly deflated under police investigation.


22. The Squirrel Sabotage

A Tennessee motorist filed a $5,000 claim after finding his car covered in acorns and scratches. The culprit? A rogue squirrel with a grudge (or perhaps a bad nut stash). The insurance company, however, nutted out the truth: the damage was likely self-inflicted by squirrels seeking winter snacks, a claim not covered under their policy.


23. The Flaming Flamingo Fiasco

A Florida driver claimed their car burst into flames due to a flamingo flying into the engine. While the image is comical, the $12,000 claim was deemed fowl play by the insurance company. Their investigation revealed a faulty electrical system, leaving the flamingo out of the hot seat.


24. The Ghostly Garage Guzzle

A Texas homeowner submitted a $2,000 claim for their mysteriously vanishing gas. They blamed a poltergeist with a taste for high-octane, but the insurance company refused to play along. A faulty fuel gauge turned out to be the real culprit, sending the claim spiraling into the realm of the unexplained (unless you count bad mechanics).


These are just a few examples of the most bizarre auto insurance claims in America. They are a testament to the unexpected and unusual nature of life. While these cases may seem outrageous, comical, or unbelievable, they serve as a reminder of the importance of comprehensive insurance coverage and the need to be prepared for the unexpected.

Comentários


bottom of page